Icons contest 2012: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| (4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
...Not quite right done, I'm afraid. Too saturated for my taste! | ...Not quite right done, I'm afraid. Too saturated for my taste! | ||
I'm having really hard time dealing with "consistency" of presented icons. Shadow? No shadow? Different shadow colors and shapes? | I'm having really hard time dealing with "consistency" of presented icons. Shadow? No shadow? Different shadow colors and shapes? | ||
* Craig: | |||
Doesn't work for me as it is with the theming background, but otherwise the best of the 3 for me. Seems a little confused and complicated. | |||
==michal== | ==michal== | ||
| Line 47: | Line 50: | ||
I'm concerned about using pure black and too dark grays for such vital parts of icons. On dark themes those will disappear.<br /> | I'm concerned about using pure black and too dark grays for such vital parts of icons. On dark themes those will disappear.<br /> | ||
Not enough inventiveness. Mostly it's just recoloring and simplification of our existing set. | Not enough inventiveness. Mostly it's just recoloring and simplification of our existing set. | ||
*Craig: | |||
Too simple, all that blue won't work across many desktops etc | |||
==yakila== | ==yakila== | ||
| Line 63: | Line 69: | ||
=== New Proposal === | === New Proposal === | ||
After analyzing the current Icons in Scribus, this is my result: | After analyzing the current Icons in Scribus, this is my result:<br /> | ||
- We have about 150 Icons | - We have about 150 Icons<br /> | ||
- If we are doing new icons for all of them, this will take two to four weeks of work. | - If we are doing new icons for all of them, this will take two to four weeks of work.<br /> | ||
- I do not know, if those three guys are aware of this. | - I do not know, if those three guys are aware of this.<br /> | ||
- The Tango Icons do not fit too well for us. | - The Tango Icons do not fit too well for us.<br /> | ||
- But the ones from Inkscape do. | - But the ones from Inkscape do.<br /> | ||
Could we just use the Inkscape-Icons, and add the ones we need in the same style? | Could we just use the Inkscape-Icons, and add the ones we need in the same style? | ||
[[File:Scribus icons comparison.png]] | [[File:Scribus icons comparison.png]] | ||
Claudia - Why don't you think the tango icons we have now work? However, yes, we could add the ones we need in the same style if we were to change.. | |||
I still think we need the ability to flip to B&W for some users. | |||
--[[User:Cbradney|Cbradney]] 16:09, 6 May 2012 (CEST) | |||
Latest revision as of 14:09, 6 May 2012
Proposals
jimmyvolatile
Proposal
Downloads:
Comments
- Add your comment... --Ale 16:03, 12 April 2012 (CEST)
- Vlada:
Pros:
Grouping similar tasks by color is a nice touch...
Cons:
...Not quite right done, I'm afraid. Too saturated for my taste!
I'm having really hard time dealing with "consistency" of presented icons. Shadow? No shadow? Different shadow colors and shapes?
- Craig:
Doesn't work for me as it is with the theming background, but otherwise the best of the 3 for me. Seems a little confused and complicated.
michal
Proposal
Comments
- Add your comment... --Ale 16:05, 12 April 2012 (CEST)
- Vlada:
Pros:
User gave us icons at right sizes (according to attached preview image).
Almost pixel-perfect.
Clean and simple.
Cons:
I'm concerned about using pure black and too dark grays for such vital parts of icons. On dark themes those will disappear.
Not enough inventiveness. Mostly it's just recoloring and simplification of our existing set.
- Craig:
Too simple, all that blue won't work across many desktops etc
yakila
Proposal
Comments
- Add your comment... --Ale 16:05, 12 April 2012 (CEST)
- Vlada:
Not sure what to think, yet. It's all too fuzzy for me.
New Proposal
After analyzing the current Icons in Scribus, this is my result:
- We have about 150 Icons
- If we are doing new icons for all of them, this will take two to four weeks of work.
- I do not know, if those three guys are aware of this.
- The Tango Icons do not fit too well for us.
- But the ones from Inkscape do.
Could we just use the Inkscape-Icons, and add the ones we need in the same style?
Claudia - Why don't you think the tango icons we have now work? However, yes, we could add the ones we need in the same style if we were to change..
I still think we need the ability to flip to B&W for some users. --Cbradney 16:09, 6 May 2012 (CEST)