How to file a bug report

From Scribus Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search


Scribus MantisBT @

Software development is almost useless without testing, and that's true for Scribus as well, of course. Testing means using the software, especially development versions. For Scribus this is currently the version1.5.8 series, which will one day become Scribus version 1.(stable-version + 2) bugs, for example v1.4 becomes v1.6.

Bugs, when discovered, need to be reported to let the developers know that something's wrong or at least seems to be wrong, so the problem can be fixed, if necessary. Moreover, the developers need to know what users need. In this case, someone who is missing a feature or has a great idea, should also let the team know about it.

In both cases, the procedure is the same. There is a software called bug tracking system, in Scribus' case this is Mantis. A bug tracking system allows developers to keep track of, discuss and review bug reports and RFEs (requests for enhancements). If you want to help to improve Scribus or absolutely need a feature, you are advised to use it.

How to create an account

Scribus Mantis Bugtracker Signup Page
Warning Warning: Due to spam abuse, the signup page has been disabled. Request an account on one of the Scribus mailing lists (scribus-dev preferably, though scribus-user should also do)

First, visit the signup page.

  1. Enter a login name, your email address and the digits displayed.
  2. Then click Signup and wait until your account has been confirmed and you received a password.

You can change your personal preferences any time in the tab "My account", provided you are logged in.

Please take the time to check the different options. They may or may not be useful for you.

Before filing a bug

If something doesn't work as expected or you think you have the idea of the century, please don't start firing up bug reports galore. Chances are good someone has already had the same problem, perhaps even the same great idea. Here are Five steps are recommended to ensure your report won't be closed as "duplicate" or "no change required".

  1. Read the documentation and rummage this wiki. There are lots of informations in different languages available, and perhaps someone has already turned his own experiences into a wiki article.
  2. Try to really use Scribus and learn about its concepts. Compared to other DTP programs, Scribus is not so hard to learn, but it is still quite different from, say, a word processor.
  3. Tell the mailing list about your problem/idea. Things normally get sorted out quickly. Often enough, a supposed bug is just lack of experience. It is also recommended to search the mailing list archives for keywords.
  4. Ask questions on IRC. This is especially useful for "real time" support.
  5. If your questions still haven't been answered, you should browse the bug database. You can search for keywords. As you can see on the screenshot below, you can enter a keyword in the "Search" field. Then click Apply, and Mantis will search for all reports containing the string. If you don't know the correct English word to search for, you can skim the multilingual Glossary for a translation. If you use a non-English version of Scribus and want to look up the English names of menu items, just switch the Scribus interface to English: File > Preferences > General > Language

In case the bug has allready been reported, there is no need to create a duplicate entry, but you can leave a comment that confirms the existing bug, or bring some more context or shed some light on the issue.

Mantis searching.png

You will notice that the reports are colored differently. Here is the color legend:


New The bug/RFE is reported, and no decision has been made as to how to handle it.
Feedback Feedback is required from either the original reporter or someone who added a note to the report. This happens quite often in cases where an issue can't be reproduced.
Acknowledged Once the team has decided a suggestion is worth keeping in mind for further development, the status is changed to "acknowledged". This is mostly the case with RFEs.
Confirmed If a reported bug could be reproduced by others, the status will change to "confirmed". This is what usually happens to bug reports.
Assigned A bug or RFE is assigned to a developer for fixing it or adding a feature.
Resolved A bug or RFE is resolved. That doesn't necessarily mean a developer wrote any code. If things can't or need not be fixed, the issue will be resolved as well.
Closed The end of a life span of a report. If all works well, the issue will finally be closed, and the scary number of reports/requests is a bit smaller.

How to file a bug report

Lets suppose you have searched through the bugs database and found out that the bug had not yet been reported. Now, it will be usefull to try to reproduce the bug, and to find out what is the simplest situation where it happens. This will help the developper to get a grip on the bug. You are then ready to file the bug report.

Scribus MantisBT New Bug/Feature Report/Request form

To file a bug report, you have to click on the Report Issue link in your browser. You will be presented a page with lots of fields for entries:

  • Categories: Choose a category you think your report fits best. If you can't find an appropriate category, choose "General".
  • Reproducibility: If you report a bug, can you reproduce it? How often does it happen? Choose the appropriate degree of frequency. RFEs have the reproducibility "Always", since the feature is always missing, until the issue is resolved.
  • Select Profile: In your personal preferences you can create user profiles for your reports. This is especially useful if you use more than one OS. You create a profile for each operating system, and if you file a report on an issue that occured on a particular system, you simply choose the profile instead of inserting the data (Platform, OS, OS Version) by hand all the time.
  • Platform: Insert your CPU platform (e. g. x86, x86-64, PPC)
  • OS: Your operating system (e. g. Linux, Windows, OS X)
  • OS Version: e. g. Debian 3.1, SuSE 10.1, Win2000, OS X 10.3
  • Product Version: Scribus has many incarnations: the stable branch (1.4x), the developer branch (1.5). Make sure you choose the right one from the drop down menu.
  • Product Build: This is especially important if you are using svn versions of Scribus. You find the relevant date in Scribus under Help > About Scribus. The date is of such importance, because the source code changes almost daily. An issue you report may very well already be resolved, in which case you will receive the recommendation to try current svn. Please don't report issues for old versions of Scribus.
Scribus MantisBT Bug Report form continued

If you have finished the preparations, you finally start writing:

  • Summary: A short description of your report. This will become the "headline" in the bug tracker.

  • Description: Describe your issue as precisely as possible, but keep it concise. No Novels here! It may also be helpful to upload some screenshots (see below). If you file a feature request, please add a real world scenario. The team needs examples to understand what the idea is and how this new feature would help people to work better and more efficiently. In other words, try to describe not only what and how, but also why.

  • Steps to reproduce: If you are able to reproduce a bug, please write down the steps necessary for reproduction on other machines.

  • Additional information: If you think other information, e. g. postings from the mailing list or messages from a debugger, are useful in this context, you can add them here.

Scribus MantisBT Bug Report form attachment function

You're almost done now, but you may want to upload a file, a screenshot for instance, or a Scribus sample file.

Click Search or enter the path to the file on your hard drive or a URL.

If you don't want a report to be seen by other reporters, but only the team, you can switch the status to "Private". This may be the case if you discover issues with an image that is protected by copyrights. Switch to "Private", and only a handful of people will see the file.

Once everything is to your satisfaction, click Submit Report. Done!

Enhanced Features

Personalised View

Provided you are logged in, you can choose a more clearly laid out view of the bug tracker. Click the link My view, and Mantis presents a structured view of recently changed issues:

Mantis my view.png

Left column    Right column
Unassigned reports    Your reports
Resolved reports    All reports recently modified
Reports monitored by you